Open Accessibility Menu

“Me Too.” Other Patient’s Assault Complaints against a Defendant Doctor

Woodruff Johnson & Evans Law Offices

undefinedAre reports of inappropriate touching made by other victims admissible in a sexual assault case? This question recently came up in a civil case against a physician. The short answer to the question is “yes,” as long as the evidence is offered for some purpose other than as proof of the doctor’s inclination to behave in a certain way.

The case involves several women who allege that the same physician inappropriately touched them during medical examinations. Freedom of Information Act requests to the local police department and the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation reveal other women had previously made complaints against the same doctor. The common denominators for all of the victims are that the inappropriate touching occurred during a physical examination, the women had seen the doctor on prior occasions without such touching and the women could not conceive of a legitimate purpose for the inappropriate touching in the context of the examination.

Not surprisingly, the doctor is seeking to prevent evidence about the other complaints from being used against him. The applicable rule of evidence is Illinois Rule 404(b). (Rule 404(b) is titled, “Other Crimes, Wrongs Or Acts.”) While the rule limits the general use of other bad acts, it allows this evidence under certain circumstances:

Such evidence may be admissible for other purposes, such as proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity or absence of mistake or accident.

Here, the women seek to prove that the doctor has a modus operandi. Not only has he previously sexually assaulted women in a similar fashion, his defense is that the inappropriate touching is acceptable because he is a physician conducting an examination. Thus, evidence of the prior assaults will be probative to show the physician’s intent, plan and absence of mistake.

Victims of abuse, particularly at the hands of a doctor, teacher, or clergy, should be allowed to be heard. Often evidence is equivocal and amounts to “he said, she said.” Juries should know when it’s really “he said, she said and she said and she said.”

Categories:
  • "I had an awesome experience with Dexter Evans!"

    "I was recently injured in an auto accident and Dexter Evans handled my case. He is the best. Awesome experience. Definitely would recommend to anyone!"

  • "They always keep in touch & are quick to respond."

    "I want to thank attorney Jon Walker for all his work on my worker's comp case. He explains everything in detail to you so you understand. Always kept in touch, you didn't have ..."

  • "I will definitely recommend them!"

    "I was injured in an auto accident and Dexter Evans handled my case. He was awesome. I will definitely recommend them to friends and family."

  • "I was very happy with the outcome of my case!"

    "A friend referred me to Woodruff Johnson & Evans. Attorney Jay Johnson explained the process so that I understood what was going on with my case. He was responsive to my ..."

  • "I was very satisfied with the results!"

    "I was referred to Woodruff Johnson & Evans by a friend who had used them in the past. Everyone I had contact with was so kind and polite. My lawyer, Jay Johnson, explained the ..."

  • "Woodruff Johnson & Evans helped settled my case when the insurance company refused to pay my medical bill!"

    "I consulted the lawyers from Woodruff Johnson & Evans and they settled my case when the insurance company refused to pay my medical bill! I think I will recommend people to ..."

  • "Dexter Evans was incredible at handling my auto-accident case & provided constant communication about any questions or concerns I had!"

    "Dexter (DJ) Evans was incredible at handling my auto-accident case and provided constant communication about any questions or concerns I had. He addressed every concern I had ..."

  • "Steven was helpful in preparing me for a deposition and was very instrumental in gathering details about the location of my slip and fall!"

    "Steven was helpful in preparing me for a deposition and was very instrumental in gathering details about the location of my slip and fall. He negotiated what I thought was a ..."

View All Testimonials

Get Your Free Consultation

  • Please enter your First Name.
  • Please enter your Last Name.
  • This isn't a valid phone number.
    Please enter your phone number.
    You entered an invalid number.
  • This isn't a valid email address.
    Please enter your email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.